Hello dear
Welcome To Gotham Pizza
At Gotham Pizza, located in the heart of New York City, passion meets tradition with every slice. Established to deliver quality pizza that resonates with local flavors, Gotham is renowned for its rich, flavorful sauces and perfectly crispy crusts. Their menu features an array of mouthwatering options, from the classic Margherita to innovative chicken cutlet pies. Diners rave about the freshness of ingredients like real Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese and homemade marinara. Many return, drawn by delightful experiences and the warm, friendly service. Whether for a quick lunch or indulging in a comforting dinner, Gotham Pizza is a cherished staple in the community.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Regular Pizza Slice
BBQ Chicken 12" Pizza With 1 Topping
12" Buffalo Chicken Pizza
12" BBQ Chicken Pizza
About
Gotham Pizza
Welcome to Gotham Pizza, a delightful gem nestled at 1667 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028, where classic pizza takes on a modern twist. Here, you step into a world where each slice tells a story, echoing the vibrant spirit of New York City. With a reputation for excellence, Gotham Pizza has garnered a loyal following, making it a must-visit for both locals and tourists.
Gotham Pizza offers an extensive menu that celebrates the rich traditions of Italian pizza-making. Their flagship options — like the Grandma Pizza Slice — feature homemade marinara sauce, sumptuous mozzarella, and a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil, all crowned with fresh basil. At only US$4.00, this is a steal for a taste of authentic New York pizza.
- 16" Regular Pizza: A classic with real parmigiano-reggiano cheese for just US$19.95.
- Margherita Pizza: Fresh mozzarella and homemade marinara, priced at US$25.95.
- Pepperoni Pizza: The quintessential favorite for US$23.95.
- White Pizza: A creamy mix of mozzarella and ricotta for US$23.95.
- Chicken Cutlet Pizza: Topped generously with chicken cutlets, available for US$26.95.
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza: Spicy buffalo chicken paired with ranch dressing, priced at US$25.95.
Gotham Pizza understands what it means to indulge in a great meal. As one customer, Hassan Hashi, eloquently puts it, their crust is perfectly crispy, and the sauce bursts with rich flavor. The gooey, cheesy goodness transforms each bite into a moment of joy. Plus, their amazing lunch special of two slices and a soda or water for just US$6.00 highlights their commitment to offering great value without compromising quality.
But it’s not just the food that makes Gotham special. The warm and inviting atmosphere, combined with fast and accurate service, creates an experience worth returning to, as AJ shared about his delightful visit. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice on your lunch break or settling in for a family meal, Gotham Pizza has something for everyone.
This isn’t just about pizza; it’s about community and nostalgia. As Georgiana Cech reminiscently notes, it’s heartwarming to know that a place like Gotham Pizza stands the test of time, allowing families to create lasting memories over delectable slices.
So, if you find yourself in the neighborhood, make it a point to stop by Gotham Pizza. You won’t just be getting a great meal; you’ll be indulging in a piece of New York history that lives on in every delicious bite. Experience the magic of Gotham Pizza, where great pizza and even greater memories await!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Most of the Pizza places near my family(90's & 1st) are long closed now. Happy to know you're still around to enjoy a few slices with my daughter while back in town ”
“ I recently visited Gotham Pizza and was blown away by how delicious their pizza is. The crust is perfectly crispy, the sauce is rich and flavorful, and the cheese is just the right amount of gooey goodness. I also took advantage of their lunch special: two slices of pizza and a soda or water for only 6.00. It's an incredible deal for the quality you get—definitely a steal! Whether you're in the mood for a quick lunch or a satisfying slice, Gotham Pizza is the place to go. ”
“ After ordering, it's fast, accurate, and kind ”
“ I make it a point to stop here if I am in the neighborhood. This is one of my go to spots for great pizza. ”
“ Amazing pizza for a great Price! Can’t go wrong! Had the Margarita Pizza, which was delicious, then been back here almost every evening while my 10 day visit to New York! ”
“ This was a great experience, fast delivery and great tasting chicken BBQ pizza with plenty of sauce and crispy edges. ”
“ Fast service. Got three slices (9), couldn't wait 10 minutes for a pizza pie(12). Great price. Its the heart of NYC you cannot go wrong with eating pizza from anywhere around here. Visiting from FL you know I miss this thin crust goodness Thanks guys! ”
“ Amazing pizza. It was weirdly empty when we went, but that was actually really nice. It's quiet and spacious, so dining in is strongly recommended. Shakers with cheese, garlic, salt, oregano, and paprika are available. You'll notice in my picture, my slice has a very hefty serving of most of those things :) The service was quick and simple. They take card. ”